What is a Lobotomy? Understanding Its Uses and History

Lobotomy, a controversial brain surgery that once captivated the medical world, has left an indelible mark on the history of psychiatry. This procedure, which involves cutting connections in the brain’s prefrontal cortex, was once hailed as a revolutionary treatment for mental illnesses such as depression and schizophrenia. What is a lobotomy, and why did it gain such prominence in the mid-20th century? This complex and often misunderstood surgical intervention has had a profound impact on countless lives and has shaped our understanding of brain function.

The story of lobotomy is a journey through medical innovation, ethical dilemmas, and scientific progress. This article delves into the origins of this procedure, exploring how it was performed and its effects on patients. We’ll examine the historical context that led to its widespread use and eventual decline. Additionally, we’ll take a closer look at the risks associated with lobotomy surgery and its lasting legacy in the field of neuroscience. By understanding this chapter in medical history, we gain valuable insights into the evolution of mental health treatment and the ethical considerations that guide modern psychiatric practices.

The History of Lobotomy

Early Psychosurgery

The roots of psychosurgery can be traced back to ancient times. Evidence suggests that trepanation, a procedure involving drilling holes in the skull, was practiced as far back as 7,000 years ago. However, the modern concept of psychosurgery emerged in the late 19th century. In 1891, Swiss psychiatrist Gottlieb Burckhardt performed the first known psychosurgical procedure on six patients with severe schizophrenia. He removed small portions of their frontal, parietal, and temporal brain lobes, aiming to alleviate their symptoms. Although Burckhardt deemed three of the cases successful, his work was not well-received by the scientific community at the time.

Development of Lobotomy

The true development of the lobotomy as we know it today began in the 1930s. Portuguese neurologist Egas Moniz, inspired by the work of American scientists on brain-behavior correlations, invented the procedure known as prefrontal leukotomy. Moniz, along with his colleague Pedro Almeida Lima, performed the first modern psychosurgery in 1935. Their technique involved drilling holes in the patient’s skull and injecting pure alcohol into the prefrontal cortex to destroy nerve connections.

Moniz believed that mental illnesses were caused by faulty connections in the brain, and severing these connections could alleviate symptoms. He initially reported positive results in treating conditions such as depression and schizophrenia. However, the long-term effects and risks of the procedure were not yet fully understood.

Popularization in the United States

The lobotomy gained significant popularity in the United States through the efforts of neurologist Walter Freeman and neurosurgeon James Watts. Inspired by Moniz’s work, they performed the first prefrontal lobotomy in the United States in 1936. Freeman and Watts modified the technique, developing what became known as the standard prefrontal lobotomy.

Freeman, in particular, was instrumental in promoting the procedure. He refined the technique further, creating the transorbital lobotomy in 1946. This method involved inserting a sharp instrument through the eye socket to sever connections in the prefrontal cortex. Freeman claimed this new approach was quicker, easier, and more effective than previous methods.

The lobotomy gained widespread acceptance in the United States during the 1940s and early 1950s. Several factors contributed to its popularity:

1. Overcrowding in mental institutions: The procedure was seen as a potential solution to manage difficult patients and reduce hospital populations.
2. Lack of alternative treatments: At the time, there were few effective treatments for severe mental illnesses.
3. Media attention: Freeman actively promoted the lobotomy through various media outlets, presenting it as a miracle cure for mental disorders.
4. Nobel Prize recognition: In 1949, Egas Moniz was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his work on lobotomies, further legitimizing the procedure.

By the late 1940s, tens of thousands of lobotomies had been performed in the United States. However, concerns about the procedure’s effectiveness and ethical implications began to emerge. The introduction of antipsychotic medications in the 1950s, such as chlorpromazine, provided alternative treatments for mental illnesses. This development, combined with growing awareness of the lobotomy’s severe side effects and risks, led to a decline in its use.

Suggestion for read: 5 Common Crohn’s Disease Symptoms

How Lobotomies Were Performed

Lobotomy, a controversial brain surgery, involved severing connections in the prefrontal cortex. This procedure, once hailed as a revolutionary treatment for mental illnesses such as depression and schizophrenia, was performed using different techniques over time. The two main methods that gained prominence were the prefrontal lobotomy and the transorbital lobotomy.

Prefrontal Lobotomy

The prefrontal lobotomy, also known as the standard lobotomy, was the initial technique used to perform this brain surgery. This method involved drilling holes into the patient’s skull to access the brain. The procedure aimed to disconnect the thalamus from the frontal lobe, as doctors believed this would alleviate symptoms of mental disorders.

During a prefrontal lobotomy, surgeons would typically create multiple lesions in each lobe of the brain. The process began with the patient being placed under anesthesia. Then, the surgeon would drill or cut holes in the skull to expose the brain. Using a surgical instrument called a leucotome, the doctor would make circular lesions in the white matter of the frontal lobe.

On average, six lesions were created in each lobe.

This technique required a sterile operating room, surgical assistants, and proper medical equipment. The procedure was time-consuming and invasive, often leading to complications such as increased temperature, vomiting, bladder and bowel incontinence, and various psychological effects.

Transorbital Lobotomy

As the popularity of lobotomies grew, neurologist Walter Freeman sought to develop a quicker and less invasive method. In 1945, he introduced the transorbital lobotomy, which revolutionized the procedure and made it more accessible.

The transorbital lobotomy involved inserting a long, thin instrument through the patient’s eye socket to reach the frontal lobe. This instrument, often described as similar to an ice pick, was used to pierce the thin bone separating the eye socket from the frontal lobe. Once inserted, the surgeon would move the instrument to sever connections in the prefrontal cortex.

Freeman claimed that this new method had several advantages over the standard prefrontal lobotomy:

1. Speed: The procedure could be performed much faster, sometimes in as little as 10 minutes.
2. Simplicity: It did not require drilling holes in the skull or a full surgical team.
3. Accessibility: Freeman argued that the transorbital lobotomy could be performed without the need for a sterile operating room or surgical scrubs.

This simplified approach allowed Freeman to perform lobotomies at an unprecedented rate. He even took his practice on the road, traveling across the United States in a camper van he called the “lobotomobile.” In one notable stretch in August 1958, Freeman performed 50 transorbital lobotomies in just over four days, covering 650 miles across America’s heartland.

The transorbital lobotomy gained significant popularity due to its perceived efficiency and accessibility. However, it is crucial to note that this method, like its predecessor, carried severe risks and often resulted in devastating complications for patients.

Both the prefrontal and transorbital lobotomy techniques were based on the flawed belief that severing connections in the brain could effectively treat mental illnesses. The procedures often left patients with significant cognitive impairments, personality changes, and a range of other side effects. Some patients experienced what Freeman termed “surgically induced childhood,” where they were left with an infantile personality and required a period of maturation to recover.

It’s important to understand that lobotomies, regardless of the technique used, were not a cure for mental health conditions. Instead, they often reduced the functionality of the frontal lobe, leading to a range of unintended consequences. While some patients showed improvement in their symptoms, many suffered from severe post-operative complications, including alterations in affect and personality, brain abscesses, and even death.

The widespread use of lobotomies began to decline in the 1950s with the introduction of effective antipsychotic medications, such as chlorpromazine. These new treatments provided a less invasive alternative for managing symptoms of mental illnesses, ultimately leading to the end of the lobotomy era in psychiatric care.

Effects and Risks of Lobotomy

Lobotomy, a controversial brain surgery that involved altering the prefrontal cortex, had profound effects on patients and carried significant risks. This procedure, once considered a potential treatment for mental health conditions such as depression and schizophrenia, often resulted in life-altering consequences for those who underwent it.

Short-term Side Effects

Immediately following a lobotomy, patients experienced a range of short-term side effects. These included confusion, itching, numbness, and tingling sensations. Many individuals also developed heightened sensitivity to light and sound. Some patients exhibited a marked reduction in tension or agitation, which was initially seen as a positive outcome. However, this often came at the cost of other cognitive and emotional functions.

One of the most notable immediate effects was a state that Walter Freeman, a prominent advocate of lobotomies, termed “surgically induced childhood.” Patients often displayed an infantile personality, requiring a period of maturation to recover. This resulted in a significant loss of independence and self-awareness.

Long-term Complications

The long-term complications of lobotomies were severe and often irreversible. Many patients experienced a range of cognitive and emotional impairments that persisted long after the surgery. These included:

1. Personality changes: Patients often became apathetic, passive, and lacked initiative. They showed a decreased depth and intensity in their emotional responses to life.
2. Cognitive decline: Many individuals suffered from poor concentration, reduced intellectual range, and difficulty imagining themselves in others’ positions.
3. Emotional blunting: Patients frequently exhibited a lack of spontaneity and responsiveness, leading to social detachment.
4. Physical complications: Chronic headaches, seizures (the most common side effect), and loss of bladder or bowel control were common long-term issues.
5. Neurological problems: Some patients developed intracranial hemorrhages, brain abscesses, or even dementia.
6. Relapse of previous symptoms: In many cases, the original mental health symptoms that the lobotomy aimed to treat eventually returned.

The case of Rosemary Kennedy, sister of John F. Kennedy, serves as a high-profile example of a failed lobotomy. After undergoing the procedure in 1941 to treat seizures and mood swings, she lost her ability to walk and talk, suffering permanent physical disability and personality changes.

Mortality Rate

The risks associated with lobotomies were not limited to cognitive and emotional impairments; they also carried a significant risk of death. During the 1940s, when lobotomies were at the height of their popularity, the average mortality rate was approximately 5%. However, some reports suggest that the death rate could have been even higher, with one source citing a mortality rate of 14% for procedures performed by Walter Freeman.

It’s important to note that the true effects and risks of lobotomies are difficult to quantify accurately. This is due to the lack of standardized reporting, evaluation, and record-keeping during the era when these procedures were performed. Many complications and deaths may have gone unreported or underreported.

The severe risks and complications associated with lobotomies eventually led to their decline. With the introduction of antipsychotic medications in the 1950s, more effective and less invasive treatments for mental health conditions became available. This development, combined with growing awareness of the devastating outcomes of lobotomies, led to the procedure falling out of favor in the medical community.

Today, lobotomies are no longer performed in the United States, and they are widely recognized as a dark chapter in the history of psychiatric treatment. The legacy of this controversial procedure serves as a reminder of the importance of ethical considerations and evidence-based practices in mental health care.

Conclusion

The exploration of lobotomy’s history and impact sheds light on the complex journey of psychiatric treatment. This controversial procedure, once seen as a breakthrough, serves as a stark reminder of the importance of ethical considerations and evidence-based practices in mental health care. The transition from lobotomies to modern treatments highlights the ongoing evolution in our understanding of the human brain and mental health disorders.

As we reflect on this chapter in medical history, it’s clear that the pursuit of mental health solutions requires a delicate balance of innovation and caution. At Inquire Talk, we understand the significance of mental health and well-being in relationships, offering online counseling services designed to support individuals and couples in managing stress, promoting emotional well-being, and fostering better relationships. The lessons learned from the lobotomy era continue to shape our approach to mental health care, emphasizing the need for compassionate, scientifically sound treatments that respect the dignity and well-being of every individual.

FAQs

What was the primary purpose of performing a lobotomy?
Lobotomies were primarily used to address mental health issues or to alleviate their symptoms. Initially, it was believed that targeting the frontal lobe could reduce aggressive behaviors in patients with conditions like schizophrenia.

Can you explain what a lobotomy is and provide a brief history?
A lobotomy is a form of psychosurgery that was widely administered during the 1940s. Dr. Walter J. Freeman II was notably prolific in this field, performing over 3,500 lobotomies by the late 1960s. The procedure saw a decline in popularity in the mid-1950s with the advent of less invasive treatments, such as antidepressants and antipsychotics.

What were the adverse effects associated with lobotomies?
While outcomes varied, lobotomies often resulted in severe complications. Patients could experience intracranial hemorrhage, epilepsy, significant changes in personality and affect, brain abscesses, dementia, and in some cases, death.

What led to the discontinuation and illegality of lobotomies?
Lobotomies garnered significant criticism, particularly in the 1940s and 50s, for being inhumane. This criticism was most vehement in the Soviet Union, which completely banned the procedure in 1950.

Here are few certified therapists who you can get in touch and book a therapy session with:

Jennifer Campbell Kirk

Steve Manley

Ioanna Matte