Circumcision: Comprehensive Guide for Parents and Guardians

Circumcision, a surgical procedure to remove the foreskin of the penis, has been a topic of debate and discussion for centuries. This practice, performed on newborns, children, or adults, has deep roots in various cultures and religions worldwide. It also has an impact on health, sparking ongoing conversations about its benefits and risks among medical professionals, parents, and individuals considering the procedure.

This comprehensive guide aims to provide parents and guardians with essential information to make an informed decision about circumcision. It covers the meaning of circumcision, compares circumcised and uncircumcised penises, and explores the medical benefits and potential risks. The guide also delves into the cultural and religious significance of the practice, discusses different circumcision techniques such as the flower cut and V-cut, and examines the pros and cons to consider when deciding whether to circumcise a child or opt for voluntary medical male circumcision later in life.

What is Circumcision?

Definition

Circumcision is a surgical procedure that involves the removal of the foreskin, which is the hood of skin covering the glans (head) of the penis. This practice has ancient roots, dating back to pre-biblical times in Egypt, where it was performed to improve male hygiene. Today, circumcision has an impact on health and is carried out for various reasons, including religious, cultural, medical, and personal preferences.

Procedure

The circumcision procedure is typically performed on newborns within the first 10 days of life, often within 48 hours after birth. It usually takes place in a hospital setting and is conducted by a pediatrician, family doctor, or obstetrician. In some cases, particularly for religious ritual circumcisions, the procedure may be performed at home.

For newborn circumcision, the infant is placed in a restraint to prevent movement during the procedure. The penis and surrounding area are thoroughly cleaned, and an anesthetic is administered to minimize pain. This can be in the form of an injection at the base of the penis or a topical cream.

The actual procedure involves the following steps:

1. The baby is positioned on their back with arms and legs gently restrained.
2. The penis is cleaned.
3. The foreskin is separated from the head of the penis.
4. A scalpel is used to remove the foreskin.

The entire process typically takes between 15 to 30 minutes to complete.

Types of Circumcision

There are three primary techniques used for circumcision, each utilizing a different device:

1. Gomco Clamp: This is the most common method. It separates the foreskin from the glans, protects the penis head, and helps control bleeding. A scalpel is then used to remove the foreskin.
2. Mogen Clamp: This technique uses clamps resembling scissors or pliers to expose the glans. Once properly exposed, a scalpel removes the foreskin.
3. Plastibell Device: This approach involves placing a plastic ring between the foreskin and the glans. A string is tied around the foreskin, pushing it against the ring. The foreskin is then removed with a scalpel, and the plastic ring falls off naturally after about a week.

The choice of technique depends on the physician’s experience and comfort level, as all three methods are considered equally effective. However, there are some differences in procedure duration and potential complications. The Mogen clamp typically requires the least training and procedure time, usually taking less than five minutes.

It has an association with less bleeding and fewer complications. In contrast, the Gomco clamp and Plastibell methods can take up to 10 minutes and are associated with more bleeding and complications.

It’s important to note that while circumcision is common in newborns, it can also be performed on older children and adults. However, these later-life procedures usually occur in an operating room under general anesthesia and come with additional risks.

Medical Benefits and Risks

Potential health benefits

Circumcision has an impact on health and offers several potential benefits. These include:

1. Easier hygiene: The procedure makes it simpler to wash the penis, although uncircumcised boys can be taught to clean beneath the foreskin regularly.
2. Lower risk of urinary tract infections (UTIs): While UTIs are generally uncommon in males, they occur less frequently in circumcised individuals. Serious infections early in life can lead to kidney problems later.
3. Reduced risk of sexually transmitted infections: Circumcised men might have a lower risk of certain sexually transmitted infections, including HIV. However, safe sex practices, including condom use, remain crucial.
4. Prevention of penile problems: Circumcision can help prevent phimosis, a condition where the foreskin is difficult or impossible to retract, which can lead to inflammation of the foreskin or glans.
5. Lower risk of penile cancer: Although rare, penile cancer is less common in circumcised men. Additionally, cervical cancer is less frequent in the female sexual partners of circumcised men.

It’s important to note that while these benefits exist, the risks associated with not being circumcised are relatively rare and can be mitigated with proper penile care.

Possible risks and complications

As with any surgical procedure, circumcision has potential risks and complications:

1. Bleeding: This is the most common complication, usually involving a few drops of blood that can be controlled with gentle pressure. In rare cases, more severe bleeding may occur, particularly in individuals with underlying blood disorders.
2. Infection: Although infrequent when performed under sterile conditions, infections can occur. These range from minor issues to rare but serious complications such as meningitis, necrotizing fasciitis, or sepsis.
3. Surgical errors: These can include removing too little or too much foreskin, resulting in an unsatisfactory appearance or the need for surgical revision.
4. Adhesions and skin bridges: Incomplete removal of adhesions during the procedure can lead to an asymmetric appearance or the formation of skin bridges, which may require surgical correction.
5. Meatitis and meatal stenosis: Inflammation of the urethral opening (meatitis) can occur, potentially leading to narrowing of the opening (meatal stenosis) in some cases.
6. Rare complications: These include chordee (penile curvature), hypospadias, epispadias, urethrocutaneous fistula, and in extremely rare cases, partial or complete glans amputation.

It’s crucial to note that severe complications are extremely rare, especially when the procedure is performed by experienced healthcare professionals in a medical setting. Parents considering circumcision for their child should discuss the potential benefits and risks with their healthcare provider to make an informed decision.

Suggestion for read: How to Decode Female Sexual Signals

Cultural and Religious Significance

Circumcision has an impact on various cultures and religions worldwide, with its practice dating back to ancient times. This surgical procedure has deep-rooted significance in many societies, often serving as a mark of cultural identity or religious importance.

Circumcision in Different Religions

Judaism holds circumcision as a fundamental practice. Known as brit milah or bris, it symbolizes the covenant between God and the Jewish people. According to the Torah, God commanded Abraham to circumcise himself and his male descendants on the eighth day of life. The Talmud considers brit milah equal to all other mitzvot (commandments). Jews who voluntarily avoid this practice are believed to face kareth, the extinction of the soul and denial of a share in the world to come.

Islam is the largest religious group practicing male circumcision. While not mentioned in the Quran, it is discussed in some hadith and the sunnah. Islamic scholars have varying views on its importance. Some consider it obligatory, while others view it as recommendable or permissible. Unlike in Judaism, there is no fixed age for circumcision in Islam, with many Muslim children undergoing the procedure in late childhood or early adolescence.

Christianity has diverse perspectives on circumcision. While it is not prescribed in most forms of Christianity, some denominations practice it. The Coptic Christians in Egypt and Ethiopian Orthodox Christians, representing some of the oldest forms of Christianity, retain male circumcision as part of their traditions. The circumcision of Jesus is celebrated as a feast day in many Christian denominations.

Hinduism and Buddhism appear to have a neutral stance on circumcision, with Hindu canons making no reference to the practice. Some Hindu gurus consider it to be against nature and God’s design. Sikhism, on the other hand, criticizes the practice and does not circumcise infants.

Cultural Practices

Beyond religious contexts, circumcision has been practiced for thousands of years in various cultures worldwide. In sub-Saharan Africa, many ethnic groups view circumcision as an integral part of a rite of passage to manhood. For instance, the Dogon and Dowayo of West Africa and the Xhosa of South Africa consider the foreskin as the feminine element of the penis, and its removal, along with other tests, marks the transition from boyhood to manhood.

In some Pacific Island and Australian aboriginal traditions, circumcision is part of initiation rites. The practice is nearly universal in Melanesian islands such as Fiji and Vanuatu, and is common in Polynesian islands like Samoa, Tonga, and Niue. In Samoa, the procedure is often accompanied by a celebration.

The prevalence of circumcision varies significantly across different regions. It is almost universal in countries where Muslim and Jewish faiths are commonplace, such as Iran, Iraq, Yemen, and Israel. In Western countries, the rates differ considerably, with the United States having a high prevalence (71%) compared to European countries like Germany (11%) and Ireland (1%).

Tradition plays a crucial role in the continuation of this practice in many cultures. For example, in Bendel State in southern Nigeria, 43% of men cited tradition as their primary motivation for circumcision. This underscores the deep-rooted cultural significance of the practice in many societies, extending beyond religious or medical considerations.

Making the Decision

Factors to Consider

When deciding whether to circumcise a newborn, parents and guardians should carefully weigh several factors. Cultural and religious traditions often play a significant role in this decision. For many Jewish and Muslim families, circumcision has an impact on their religious practices and is an important part of their faith. Some parents may also choose circumcision based on family tradition or personal preferences.

Medical considerations are another crucial aspect to evaluate. While the American Academy of Pediatrics states that the benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks, they do not explicitly recommend the procedure for all newborns. Some potential health benefits include a slightly lower risk of urinary tract infections (UTIs) in the first year of life, a reduced risk of certain sexually transmitted infections later in life, and prevention of foreskin infections and phimosis.

However, it’s important to note that these benefits can also be achieved through proper hygiene and safe sex practices. Parents should also consider the potential risks associated with the procedure, such as bleeding, infection, and injury to the penis, although these complications are rare.

Esthetic and hygiene factors may also influence the decision. Some parents believe that a circumcised penis is easier to keep clean, while others prefer the natural appearance of an uncircumcised penis. It’s worth noting that proper hygiene can be maintained for both circumcised and uncircumcised penises with appropriate care and education.

Financial considerations may also come into play. Not all insurance companies cover the cost of circumcision, so parents should check with their provider regarding coverage before making a decision.

Talking to Your Doctor

Consulting with a healthcare provider has an impact on making an informed decision about circumcision. During these discussions, parents should feel comfortable asking questions and expressing any concerns they may have. Healthcare professionals can provide detailed information about the procedure, its potential benefits and risks, and address any misconceptions.

When speaking with a doctor, parents should inquire about:

1. The specific technique used for the procedure
2. Pain management options during and after the circumcision
3. Potential complications and how they are managed
4. Post-procedure care instructions
5. Signs of infection or other issues to watch for during recovery

It’s also important to discuss any family history of bleeding disorders, as this can affect the decision to circumcise. Additionally, parents should be aware that in some cases, circumcision may need to be delayed. For example, premature babies or those with certain medical conditions may not be eligible for immediate circumcision.

Ultimately, the decision to circumcise is a personal one that should be made after careful consideration of all factors and thorough discussions with healthcare providers. Parents should feel empowered to make the choice that best aligns with their values, beliefs, and their child’s well-being.

Conclusion

Circumcision has a significant influence on various aspects of life, from health considerations to cultural and religious practices. This guide has explored the procedure’s meaning, potential benefits and risks, and its importance in different societies worldwide. Parents and guardians face a complex decision when considering circumcision for their children, weighing medical advice, personal beliefs, and family traditions. It’s crucial to approach this choice with thorough research and open discussions with healthcare providers to make an informed decision that aligns with the child’s best interests.

Ultimately, the decision to circumcise is deeply personal and should reflect the family’s values and circumstances. At Inquire Talk, we understand the significance of mental health and well-being in relationships. Seeking professional help through online therapy and psychotherapy can provide valuable support to manage stress and promote emotional well-being. By focusing on personal growth and setting healthy boundaries, individuals can work towards creating more fulfilling and balanced relationships in their lives. Whether choosing circumcision or not, the most important factor is ensuring the child’s overall health and well-being, both physically and emotionally.

FAQs

1. Is the presence of both parents required for a child’s circumcision?
   According to the British Medical Association (BMA) guidelines, consent for a child’s circumcision should ideally be obtained from both parents, as highlighted by a notable case involving Dr. Mehat.
2. Can parents stay with their child during the circumcision procedure?
   Parents have the option to be present during the circumcision, wait in another room, or decide against the procedure entirely.
3. Is the consent of both parents necessary for a child’s circumcision?
   It is important for both parents to agree and provide consent for their child’s circumcision, reflecting their joint parental authority.
4. What are some reasons parents might choose not to circumcise their child?
   One medical reason to avoid circumcision is that the foreskin protects the tip of the penis. Removing the foreskin can lead to irritation and potentially cause the penis opening to narrow, which might necessitate surgical intervention to correct urination issues.

Here are few certified therapists who you can get in touch and book a therapy session with:

Tommaso Palumbo

Paula Brown

Carmen Winch